Persuasion
Persuasion
Persuasion was Jane Austen’s last completed novel. Writing to her niece Fanny Knight in March 1817 she noted: “I have a something ready for Publication, which may perhaps appear about a twelvemonth hence. It is short, about the length of Catherine”. By Catherine she meant Northanger Abbey.
Jane Austen was a prolific correspondent with her sister Cassandra but sadly after Janes’s death, perhaps desirous of curating her sister’s legacy, Cassandra destroyed many of the letters between them. Of course, in doing so, the remaining small nuggets about Jane’s character and craft are few and far between.
Jane Austen referred to this final book as The Elliots - and must have talked about it to her relatives as such. Tragically she died in July 1817, so the book was published by her brother under the title Persuasion. Every author endlessly discusses what a book title should be with family and friends, and her work was the subject of much interest and pride with her relatives.
Compared to Pride and Prejudice or Emma for example, for a long time Persuasion languished in popular esteem but later it garnered more positive comment. Virginia Woolf wrote a wonderful essay about Jane Austen and her novels commenting on the "personal" quality of the novel Persuasion but saying that one of the problems of reading Jane Austen was that “of all the great writers she is the most difficult to catch in the act of greatness.” “There is a peculiar beauty and a peculiar dullness in Persuasion.”
Persuasion’s story is about Anne Elliot, now 27 years old, whose family took great pride in their lineage but lived too extravagantly and found that they needed to cut their cloth, rent out their house and move to reduce their debt. Their new tenant was an admiral and his wife. The wife's brother, Captain Frederick Wentworth, had once been engaged to Anne in 1806, but the engagement was broken when Anne was persuaded by her friends and family to end their relationship on the grounds that he was not good enough. Anne and Captain Wentworth, still both single and unattached, meet again after a separation lasting almost eight years, setting the scene for a second, well-considered chance at love and marriage for Anne - she only learned romance as she grew older and the novel is remarkably tender.
This last novel is infused with the little phrases through which her characters speak which are so familiar so that we instantly recognize similar traits amongst our own acquaintances, and so on point that we can almost hear the characters’ voices and see their facial expressions. It is full of twists and turns which endlessly reveal the characters’ main concerns over position and appearance, of doing and saying the right thing, which were a constant and precarious balancing act. Life was fragile, particularly for women.
Jane Austens’ sense of place is legendary in all her novels so much so that apparently, 50 years later, Lord Tennyson wanted to see the exact spot where Louisa Musgrove fell from the seawall in Lyme Regis.
Critics comment that Persuasion has an autumnal feeling to it, but perhaps this is because we read it with the retrospective knowledge of Jane’s imminent death. Equally it was a downcast time in England. 1816 became known as the year without a summer, a sunless time of death and famine following the eruption of Mount Tambora, a stratovolcano in Indonesia. Although 7,800 miles away from Janes home at Chawton Cottage in Hampshire, the blast remains the most powerful in recorded human history. It triggered extreme weather, poor harvests and disease in many areas around the world. Jane did mention the sunless weather and was not at all well, yet hoped her health would improve
Ultimately though, I feel that writing Persuasion was almost an act of optimism for Jane given her health and that the story itself is also optimistic and full of the possibilities of second chances. Something we all need occasionally.
25 Comments
Wonderful! I enjoyed reading this so much. I have always read the Jane Austen books and as much of articles and books of her actual life and family as I could find.
Dear Lady Carnarvon,
Thank you for such an insightful and delightful piece. I have been a devoted student of Jane Austen for many decades (though good manners—and perhaps a lady’s instinct for self-preservation—prevent me from revealing precisely how many), and your observations struck me as exactly right.
By a most agreeable coincidence, one of the leading journals devoted to Austen scholarship bears the title Persuasions. While reading your essay, I could not help but think it would sit there most comfortably indeed.
With admiration and thanks for such thoughtful writing,
Barbara Griffith
Persuasion and words.. they are an art
Lovely the pictures of persuasion and did you and lord Carnarvon have a wonderful weekend and I am fan of Downton Abbey and highcelere castle
Cutting one's cloth is an expression new to me.
jolly useful thing to do!
Cutting one's cloth is an expression new to me.
Lady Carnarvon,
I loved reading this! so beautifully written! Persuasion is one of my favourite Jane Austin Novels.Thank you so much from Vancouver!
It is a great novel - I was in Vancouver for a PBS fundraiser before covid.. loved it
Would love to to hear you read this novel or others of Jane Austen as an audiobook!
I would love to be asked!
Ah, sigh ...
Thank you for featuring Persuasion. I absolutely love this novel - I read it when I had COVID a couple years ago and it made the illness so much more bearable. She and this book will also hold a special place in my heart (and lungs!).
I appreciate her pace- of life and writing
Lovely! I have been persuaded to read Persuasion! This was a wonderful look into Jane Austen’s life for me. You have a wonderful and lovely way of writing.
Persuasion was ruined for me by having to do it for my GCE exam at age (almost) 15 ..... BUT as an adult I have since gone back to Jane Austens works, and love them all !
I read anything and everything about Jane and Cassandra and have visited many of the places associated with them.
Lady Carnarvon,
Persuasion is my favorite Jane Austen novel.
My favorite line in the 1997 movie is when Anne and Captain Harville discuss the fickleness of women in prose and verse.
And then Anne says, "But they were all written by men."
Wow!
Thank you fior another insightful blog. Jane Austen novels are so sensitively written and well worth a second read. Second chances offer another opportunity and can be so rewarding.
The more you read the better!
Dear Lady Carnarvon:
Thank you for this Monday's insightful and interesting blog.
Jane Austen's novels are some of my favorite reads.
At this moment, the world definitely needs some Persuasion.
Perpetua Crawford
Thank you for a wonderful blog so enjoy what you write Thank you very much for sharing your home and being part of the beautiful series Downton Abbey.It is always lovely to read about life in England and the interesting topics you write about Take care Regards From Downunder
Your words are like paint flowing like a river onto the canvas.
Dear Lady Carnarvon,
Thank you for this lovely post, "Persuasion" is one of my favorite Jane Austen novels. My husband and I are visiting England this June and will be staying in Hampshire.
We are very excited to visit Chawton as well as Highclere Castle, having already purchased our tickets. We cannot wait.
Thank you for your lovely blog posts
Ruth Welter, USA
Leave a Comment
- Christmas
- Community
- Dogs & Horses
- Egypt & Tutankhamun
- Entertaining
- Farm
- Filming
- Gardens
- History & Heritage
- Daily Life
- Royalty
- Cooking
- Interiors
- Heroes
- Architecture
- Cars
- Conservation
- Downton Abbey
- Events
- Gardens & Landscape
- Highclere Castle Gin
- History
- Planes
- Restoration
- Stories & Books
- Uncategorized
- Visitors
- Wildlife
Lady Carnarvon,
Thank you for such a nostalgic look at Persuasion. I dearly cherish her novels - such a view of another time of proper, stilted or hidden thoughts and words. Sometimes I think this world needs a bit of Austin’s quietness. Highclere certainly brings the scenery of that world, thanks to your care.
Her novels are timeless